The Buffet Crampon Prodige and the Yamaha YCL-255 are the two current official student Bb clarinets most US school programs actually name. Both are ABS resin instruments, both are still in the official catalogs, and both cost more at many dealers than older “student horn” prices would suggest. The useful difference is not wood versus plastic. It is bore design, pads, key plating, and which brand your teacher or rental desk already supports.
Prodige vs YCL-255 Compared
| Model | Body | Pads and keys | Approx Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buffet Prodige | ABS resin | Leather pads, silver-plated keys | $999 to $1,799 |
| Yamaha YCL-255 | ABS resin | Dealer listings describe Valentino pads, nickel-plated keys | $1,099 to $1,431 |
Prices were checked in November 2026. Neither official US product page publishes a list price. Guitar Center listed the Prodige at $999 and Alexandria Music Co. listed it at $1,799. Guitar Center listed the YCL-255 at $1,099, and both Music & Arts and The Instrument Place listed it at $1,431. A low listing is not a guaranteed street price on either horn.
Buffet Prodige: The Official Buffet Student Horn
The Prodige is Buffet Crampon’s current official student Bb clarinet in the United States (SKU BC2541-5-0ABS). Official specifications list an ABS body, leather pads, silver-plated keywork with 17 keys and 6 rings, an adjustable thumb rest, a 64mm barrel, and a pitch of 442 Hz. Buffet says the bore is digitally machined in France and Germany and is inspired by the E13, and that the instrument ships with a stackable ABS case plus a mouthpiece, reed, ligature, cap, swab, cork grease, and pencil.
That leather-pad, silver-key package is more “Buffet-like” than most student resin horns. It is still a student ABS clarinet, not a wooden E11. If a player later moves to an E11 or E12F, the brand and some of the feel will already be familiar. See our Buffet E11 review and the plastic versus wood guide for what that next step involves.
Pros
- Current official Buffet student model, with a bore Buffet describes as E13 inspired
- Leather pads and silver-plated keys, which are uncommon at this level
- Sometimes listed under $1000, which undercuts typical YCL-255 street prices
Cons
- Other dealers list it close to $1,800, so the bargain price is not consistent
- Fewer US school-band desks stock Buffet than Yamaha
- Resin tone, not grenadilla
Yamaha YCL-255: The School Standard
The YCL-255 is still Yamaha’s current official standard student Bb clarinet. Official materials describe a matte ABS resin body that is meant to resemble wood, a lighter bell without a metal ring, and an adjustable thumb rest with a strap ring. Dealer listings typically add a 65mm barrel and a Yamaha 4C mouthpiece. Yamaha does not publish a price on the official US product page.
Typical dealer prices now sit at $1,099 to $1,431, so this is no longer a bargain-bin student horn. What you are paying for is Yamaha’s intonation consistency, wide dealer and school support, and a design meant for outdoor and school-locker use. Our YCL-255 review covers the instrument in more detail. If your budget is tighter, see Best Clarinet Under $500.
Pros
- Current official Yamaha student model, widely specified by US schools
- Excellent intonation and strong resale
- Matte ABS body that will not crack with weather changes
Cons
- Typical US dealer prices of $1,099 to $1,431 sit above many student budgets
- Nickel-plated keys and a more standard student pad set than the Prodige’s leather pads
- Resin tone, not grenadilla
Which One Should You Buy?
Buy the YCL-255 if the school, rental desk, or teacher already supports Yamaha, or if you want the easier path to servicing and resale in the US. Buy the Prodige if you specifically want Buffet’s student horn, leather pads, and a later move toward an E11, and if the live price in front of you is actually competitive. Do not choose on a remembered $700 Yamaha figure or a single $999 Prodige listing. Check today’s price on the exact horn you will receive.
Neither clarinet is a wooden step-up. If the goal is grenadilla, you are looking at a used intermediate or a new E11 or YCL-450IIN, which typically sell well above student resin money. Our guides to the best intermediate clarinets and student versus intermediate versus professional clarinets map that next purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Prodige better than the YCL-255?
It is different, not automatically better. The Prodige brings Buffet’s official student bore, leather pads, and silver-plated keys. The YCL-255 brings Yamaha consistency and much wider US school support. The better buy is the one your teacher can service and the one you can actually get at a fair price.
Are these wooden clarinets?
No. Official specifications for both list ABS resin bodies. They are durable student instruments. A wooden clarinet is a later purchase, with humidity care to match.
Which is better for marching band?
Both are resin, so both are more suitable for outdoor use than a wooden clarinet. Choose the one your band already knows how to maintain. If marching is the main job, do not spend extra on a grenadilla instrument that will live in weather.