Getting a long-lasting student clarinet is often a challenge. You can simplify the search by comparing different models. Check out this Selmer CL300 vs. Etude ECL200 comparison.
I had some experience playing the clarinet, so I decided to buy one to teach my daughter some basics at home. I took my time to compare different models to find a good student clarinet before settling for one. Some of the models that I compared include Selmer CL300 and Etude ECL200. Read on to discover which one I chose and why.
What are the differences between Selmer CL300 and Etude ECL200?
| Name | Selmer CL300 | Etude ECL200 |
|---|---|---|
| Body | Plastic composite | Brushed resin |
| Keys | Nickel-silver | Nickel-silver |
| Finish | Black matte | Black |
| Accessories | Cock grease, swab, 2 Rico reeds, mouthpiece, ligature, swab | Cap, ligature, mouthpiece |
| Case | Available | Available |
| Weight | 4.4 pounds | 5.1 pounds |
| Check price here | Check price here | Check price here |
Selmer CL300 vs. Etude ECL200-How do they compare?
Construction
One of the things that distinguish these two clarinets is the body. Selmer CL300 comes in a plastic composite body, while Etude ECL200 has a brushed resin body. Etude ECL200 is a better quality clarinet that can withstand harsh treatment. When it comes to the finish, Selmer CL300 has a more professional look than Etude ECL200 since it has a matte finish. It mimics the attractive look of most wooden clarinets.
Etude ECL200 wins in this category since it is more durable than Selmer CL300.
Accessories
You will also not fail to notice a difference in the number of accessories that these clarinets come with. Selmer CL300 has numerous accessories such as a ligature, cap, mouthpiece, reeds, and maintenance gear. On the other hand, Etude ECL200 has limited accessories like a protective cap, ligature, and mouthpiece.
It does not include gear for maintaining it, such as a cleaning swab or cork grease. Since both models are low priced, they don’t include very high-quality accessories. You may need to replace essential parts like the mouthpiece or ligature of either clarinet.
Selmer CL300 wins in this category since it has more accessories than Etude ECL200.
Weight and carrying case
Choosing a lightweight clarinet is more convenient if you are planning to move it around often. Selmer CL300 is lighter than Etude ECL200. Despite this, both models come with carrying cases that make them highly portable. Etude ECL200 has a more durable carrying case that is a bit more spacious compared to that of the Selmer CL300.
So in this category, Etude ECL200 wins since it has a better case than Selmer CL300.
Selmer CL300 vs. Etude ECL200- Comparison overview
Selmer CL300 overview
Are you searching for a student clarinet that you can begin playing right out of the box? If yes, you should consider this model. This clarinet is made with beginners in mind since it is easy to set up. It comes from a reputable brand that has been making quality clarinets for a long time.
Since the Selmer CL300 has a plastic composite body, it delivers a dark and deep sound. The manufacturer also used a black matte finish to boost its appearance. The material also makes it lighter than most wooden clarinets.
This clarinet also features nickel-plated keys that do not bend easily. Though they are long-lasting, some users find them uncomfortable since some of the keys are not appropriately positioned.
Many learning musicians choose this model due to its affordable price. The accessories you can get with this student clarinet include a mouthpiece,2 Rico reeds, a cap, ligature, cork grease, and a swab. You can therefore maintain it with ease and start playing notes right away. Since it has a standard mouthpiece, you can choose to upgrade as you continue advancing your skills.
Though it comes with a functional and sturdy case, it does not have a lot of extra space for carrying accessories. Some users find the tone holes of this clarinet hard to cover.
Pros
- It is pocket-friendly
- The clarinet is easy to play
- Delivers a reasonable tone
- It contains a sturdy case
- Deep sound
Cons
- It comes with a poor quality mouthpiece
Etude ECL200 Overview
If you are a music enthusiast looking for a durable student clarinet, you should check out this model. It comes from a company that many directors and musicians trust. Etude ECL200 is a long-lasting model that has a brushed resin body.
Even young players can use this clarinet without it breaking easily since it is designed to withstand harsh treatment. If you are not certain whether a child will continue playing the clarinet, you can choose this model.
Etude ECL200 also comes in a black finish that gives it an elegant appearance. It also has nickel-silver keys that most players find comfortable using. These keys also give the clarinet a captivating look. Note that the key plating may begin wearing off after some time. If this happens, it may leave some sharp edges. If you often experience sweaty hands, you should oil and clean them regularly. If you have silver allergies, you should avoid this clarinet.
Whether you have large or small fingers, you will find this student clarinet comfortable to play since it features an adjustable thumb rest. Most users also find this clarinet easy to tune and play. It also delivers a great sound and tone that many students enjoy.
Once you choose this clarinet, you will get an ABS plastic case that accompanies it. This can protect it from harsh conditions and make it more durable. The manufacturer also offers additional accessories for this clarinet, such as a ligature and cap to protect the fragile mouthpiece.
You may have to buy things such as the cork grease and swab separately since they don’t form part of the package. Despite this, the clarinet comes at a low price. You, therefore, don’t have to worry about wasting so much cash while investing in it. Customers also get to enjoy a 30-day satisfaction guarantee for choosing this model. You, therefore, have enough time to test it and assess whether it is the right fit.
Pros
- It is solidly constructed
- Includes a comfortable thumb rest
- It has a durable carrying case
- Sounds great
- It comes with a satisfaction guarantee
Cons
- You may have to replace the ligature
Verdict: So, which is better? Selmer CL300 or Etude ECL200
Though both are affordable clarinets, I felt that Etude ECL200 was better for students since it is easy to play, solidly made, sounds great, and is more reliable. It is a quality clarinet that comes with impressive features such as an adjustable thumb rest and a brushed resin body. Though Selmer CL300 has all the accessories you need to start playing, some students report issues to do with discomfort when using the Selmer CL300. I, therefore, chose Etude ECL200 as the clear winner.
FAQs
Can I use Etude ECL200 outdoors?
Yes. Since this is not a wooden clarinet, you can use it either indoors or outdoors without the risk of damage. It even comes with a case that gives it excellent protection.
Is Etude ECL200 suitable for an intermediate player?
No. This is mainly marketed towards new players still learning how to play musical instruments. An intermediate player may need a better clarinet.
Charlotte Moore
Charlotte Moore is a Clarinetist by profession and has over time offered lessons on how to play the clarinet among other musical instruments. And while a majority of clarinet players are well versed with the process of settling with a good clarinet among other accompanying features. There is little information about clarinets. The reason why Charlotte prepared comprehensive experts touching on the various facets of the clarinet. The consolidated information will offer more insight on everything clarinets including the best stand to use, and the best plastic clarinet that you can invest in, among other information. Charlotte Moore is a devoted mother of two and a professional clarinet player.